Giampiero Bindolino, Gianluca Ghiringhelli, Sergio Ricci


The paper describes a procedure, dedicated to the preliminary sizing of an aircraft wing-box, based on a two level decomposition and on two independent optimizations. An engineering approach is followed and the most suitable model is exploited at each level in order to generate information about the wing-box structure without the need of a previous knowledge, a very important feature in the case of unconventional structures.
The first level uses a commercial structural multidisciplinary optimization code and a stick model of the wing primary structure to minimize the structural mass under global design constraints; a set of physical design variables are used referring to a schematic representation of the cross-section in terms of equivalent axial thickness supporting pure axial stress and the thickness of a box resisting to both axial and shear stresses. The second level, based on a genetic optimization, provides the minimum mass optimal design of the wing cross sections, in terms of local design variables, which safely support the internal loads supplied by the first level, under local constraints, e.g. panel buckling and stiffeners crippling, providing also a cross section stiffness in compliance with the first level design. The reported example, concerning the B747-100 wing structure, shows the capability of the approach to predict the structural weight of the wing box, an information to be used in an early stage of the aircraft design, and to suggest a set of cross sections design solutions all in compliance with both global and local requirements.

Full Text:



Flight international, dec. 1968, p.984, Dec. 1968.

G. Bindolino, G. L. Ghiringhelli, and S. Ricci. Preliminary wing-box weight estimation with aeroelastic requirements by structural optimization on simple models.

G. Bindolino, P. Mantegazza, and L. Visintini. A comparison of panel methods for potential flow calculations. In VIII Congresso Nazionale AIDAA, 23-27 September, Torino (Italy), pages pp.59–88, 1985.

E. F. Bruhn. Analysis and Design of Flight Vehicle Structures. Tri State Offset Company, Cincinnati, Ohio.

D.Li F.Y.Cheng. Genetic algorithm development for multiobjective optimization of structures. AIAA Journal, vol.36(No.6), June 1998.

G. Ghiringhelli and S. Ricci. A multi-level approach to preliminary optimization of a wing structure. In Int. Forum on Aeroelasticity and Structural Dynamics IFASD 2001, 5-7 June 2001 - Madrid (Spain), 5-7 June 2001.

J Horn. The nature of nitching: genetic algorithms and the evolution of optimal, cooperative populations. Technical report, Tech. rep., Cornell Univ., 1995.

R. K. Kapania and S. Chun. Preliminary design of a structural wing box under a twist constraint: parti. Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 41(No. 5):pp. 985–992, September-October 2004.

S. H. Macci. Semi-analytical method for predicting wing structural mass. Technical report, SAWE Paper No.2282, May 1995.

E. M. Murman, F. R. Bailey, and M. L. Johnson. Tsfoil-a computer code for two-dimensional transonic calculations, including wind-tunnel wall effects and wave drag evaluation. Technical report, NASA-SP347, March 1975.

S. A. Ragon, Z. Gurdal, R. T. Haftka, and T. J. Tzong. Bilevel design of a wing structure using response surfaces. Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 40(No. 5):pp. 985–992, September-October 2003.

L. A. Schmit and M. Mehrinfar. Multilevel optimum design of structures with fiber-composite stiffened panel components. AIAA Journal, Vol. 20(No. 1):pp. 138–147, 1982.

J. Sobieszczanski-Sobieski, B. James, and A. R. Dovi. Structural optimization by multi-level decomposition. AIAA Journal, vol.23(No.11), November 1983.

E. Torenbeek. Development and application of a comprehensive design-sensitive weight prediction method for wing structures of transport category aircraft. Technical Report Report LR-693, Delft University of Tecnology, Delft, Report LR-693, 1992.

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.19249/ams.v84i4.225


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright © 2018. All Rights Reserved.